Seventy years ago on aug 6, 1945, world war ii became a nuclear war when an atomic bomb leveled hiroshima, japan, and the world changed forever three days later, an atomic bomb destroyed the. The decision to use the atomic bomb: arguments in support note: this section is intended as an objective overview of the decision to use the atomic bomb for new students of the issue for the other side of the issue, go here. Was the second atomic bomb necessary to make japan surrender was the first bomb not sufficient update cancel i used to think that it was unnecessary - hitler. The nation is reader supported: commander of the us third fleet, stated publicly in 1946 that the first atomic bomb was an unnecessary experiment it was a mistake to ever drop it. Was the atomic bomb necessary history essay post atomic bomb prediction estimates have claimed the possibility of up to a million casualties in the a us.
Days like no other: the dropping of the atomic bombs august 6, 1945 and august 9, 1945 were days in history like no other only one country in history has ever used an atomic bomb against another nation the united states of america. Dropping the atom bomb on japan was unnecessary to end wwii the country and the vast majority of them disagreed with our use of the atomic bomb in the manner in. The atomic bomb caused a lot of unnecessary destruction when it was dropped on hiroshima it had destroyed houses and work buildings in hiroshima, such as the hospital in which dr fujii lived and worked. In contrast, many us leaders, particularly those closest to the fight against japan, believed the use of the atomic bomb was unnecessary, that japan was on the verge of surrender without it.
President obama's visit to hiroshima, nearly 71 years after it was destroyed by the first atomic bomb, inevitably raises once again the questions of why the united states dropped that bomb. He further stated, the first atomic bomb was an unnecessary experiment it was a mistake to ever drop it ( source ) he said this despite the fact that most prominent scientists were completely against it. Free essay: hundreds of thousands of innocent japanese citizens died at the hands of the atomic bomb unleashed by the united states, as told in john hersey's. This work began with my 1965 book, atomic diplomacy: hiroshima and potsdam : the use of the atomic bomb and the american confrontation with soviet power, in which i argued that the then available evidence available pointed to three major conclusions: first, that the first use of these terrible weapons was unnecessary second, that this was.
The bombing of hiroshima was one of the pivotal events of the twentieth century, yet this controversial question remains unresolved at the time, general dwight eisenhower, general douglas macarthur, and chief of staff admiral william leahy all agreed that an atomic attack on japanese cities was unnecessary. Before anyone gets upset and rages at me for having an opinion that classes with their own, i have been assigned to write an essay on why the dropping of the bomb on hiroshima was unnecessary, regardless of what my own opinion is. The atomic bomb accomplished truman's primary objective the attack on hiroshima finally convinced hirohito that the war must end, and his long-delayed conclusion was the decisive step in bringing. Atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki part of the pacific war of world war ii: atomic bomb mushroom clouds over hiroshima (left) and nagasaki (right.
Some think it was necessary as the country had no other choice, but some people think differently and believe that the atomic bomb was an unnecessary sinister and shameful act there are both valid and compelling arguments on both sides of this ethical dilemma. Necessary use of a-bombs yes, dropping the atomic bombs was necessary the offspring of a million american grandfathers would not be alive today if truman had decided to invade the island of japan. On the 70th anniversary of hiroshima-nagasaki, a new collection of us, japanese, and russian documents on the use of the atomic bomb and the end of world war ii. Hiroshima: was the atomic bomb necessary obama becomes the first sitting us president to visit hiroshima, should the united states apologise for dropping the atomic bombs on japan. With the sixty-fifth anniversary of the dropping of the atomic bomb almost upon us, there is undoubtedly going to be a flood of commentary on the wisdom of it the bomb was not necessary.
Asked to clarify, the general who directed the destruction of 67 japanese cities using mass incendiary attacks doubled down saying, the atomic bomb had nothing to do with the end of the war at. The atomic bomb had nothing to do with the end of the war at all, lemay replied admiral chester nimitz, commander in chief of the pacific fleet, sent out the following public statement : the atomic bomb played no decisive part , from a purely military standpoint, in the defeat of japan [emphasis added]. His work on the history of the decision to use the atomic weapons on hiroshima and nagasaki spans over four decades his 1995 book the decision to use the atomic bomb remains one of the definitive.
Hiroshima and nagasaki: were the atomic bombs necessary for victory updated on august 6, 2017 in his book, the decision to use the atomic bomb, alperovitz, like. This month marks the 70th anniversary of the atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki and with each passing year the historical record is ever clearer that dropping the a-bombs was unnecessary.
Was the bombing of nagasaki unnecessary to the extent that the atomic bombing was critically important to the japanese decision to surrender would it have been. Essay on the dropping of atomic bomb on japan on august 6, 1945, a b-29 bomber named enola gay dropped an atomic bomb, on hiroshima, japan hiroshima had been almost eradicated with an estimated 70 - 80 thousand people killed three days later, a second, more powerful bomb was dropped on the. He further stated that the first atomic bomb was an unnecessary experiment and that it was a mistake to ever drop it the scientists involved with the.